Compare Private Health Insurance UK (2026): How to Compare Quotes Like for Like
How to compare private health insurance properly: the settings to keep the same on every quote, the ways to compare (direct, comparison site or broker), what a good quote shows, the red flags behind a cheap price, and how to compare at renewal without losing cover.
Quick Answer
To compare health insurance fairly, get quotes from at least three insurers on exactly the same cover: the same out-patient limit, hospital list, excess, underwriting, cancer cover and extras. Change any one of those and you’re comparing different products, which is why one quote can look far cheaper than another.
You can compare by going to insurers directly, through a comparison service, or through an FCA-regulated broker, who is paid by the insurer, so it costs you nothing. If you’re already insured, compare before every renewal and ask for switch terms (CPME) so any condition covered today stays covered.
On this page
Why Comparing Health Insurance Matters
Every insurer prices from its own claims experience, so the same person can be quoted noticeably different prices for the same cover. The insurer that’s cheapest for a 35-year-old in Leeds may not be cheapest for a 60-year-old in London. And once you’re insured, most policies go up at every renewal, as you move into an older age band and treatment costs rise, which is why people who never compare tend to pay more over time.
Price isn’t the only difference. Insurers differ on how claims are handled, which hospitals are included, how cancer and mental health are covered, and what extras come as standard. Comparing properly means weighing all of that, on the same cover. More on why prices vary: why health insurance quotes differ.
The Six Settings to Keep the Same on Every Quote
These six choices change both the cover and the price. Set them once, then ask every insurer to quote on the same settings.
| Setting | What it does | What to pick |
|---|---|---|
| Out-patient limit | Pays for consultations, scans and tests before treatment | A capped allowance (often £500–£1,500 a year) keeps cost down and still covers most diagnosis. Outpatient limits explained |
| Hospital list | Decides which private hospitals you can use | Make sure your nearest hospitals are on it; only pay for central London if you’ll use it. Hospital lists outside London |
| Excess | What you pay towards a claim | An amount you could pay in a year you claim; check whether it’s per claim, per year or per person. How excess works |
| Underwriting | How past health conditions are treated | New buyers: moratorium or full medical underwriting. Switching: CPME |
| Cancer cover | How much cancer treatment and which drugs are covered | Full cancer cover is standard on many plans but not all; compare the limits, not just the headline. Cancer cover explained |
| Extras and options | Mental health, therapies, dental, optical, six-week option | Add the same extras on every quote, or none. The six-week option · mental health cover |
Not sure where to start? Our comprehensive vs basic guide explains the main levels of cover.
How to Compare Private Health Insurance in Five Steps
- Decide what you want it for. Faster diagnosis, surgery, cancer cover, mental health, or all of them. That decides which settings matter most.
- Fix your six settings (above) so every quote is like for like.
- Get at least three quotes, including at least one large insurer and one smaller one, as the cheapest for your profile isn’t always a big name.
- Check the service, not just the price. Look at independent scores: Which?’s customer survey and Moneyfacts’ star ratings are both on our best health insurance guide.
- Read the policy summary before you start. Check exclusions, limits and how claims work. New policies have a cooling-off period of at least 14 days. How cooling-off works.
Ways to Compare: Direct, Comparison Site or Broker?
| Way to compare | Good for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Going to insurers directly | Seeing each insurer’s own options in full | Slow: you repeat the same questions for every insurer, and settings are named differently, so like-for-like is harder |
| Comparison service | Seeing several prices quickly from one form | Check which insurers are included and that every quote uses the same settings |
| Broker | Advice, harder cases (health conditions, switching, families), and help at claim or renewal time | Make sure they’re FCA-regulated and compare the whole market or a wide panel. Brokers are usually paid commission by the insurer, so it shouldn’t cost you more |
Whoever you use, you can check the firm is authorised on the FCA Financial Services Register. More on brokers: should you use a health insurance broker?. Comparing cover for staff instead? See compare business health insurance.
The Insurers You’ll Be Comparing
These are the main UK insurers you’ll see in a comparison, with their latest independent scores. Full reviews and our picks by situation are in the best health insurance UK guide.
| Insurer | Which? customer score (2026) | Moneyfacts 2026 | Typical £/month |
|---|---|---|---|
| WPA | 86% (Recommended Provider) | 5★ | £36–£92 |
| Bupa | 77% | 5★ | £40–£95 |
| AXA Health | 76% | 5★ (Personal Health) | £32–£88 |
| Aviva | 74% | 5★ (Healthier Solutions) | £30–£82 |
| Vitality | 72% | 5★ | £38–£100+ |
| The Exeter | Not in survey | 5★ (Health+) | £40–£90 |
| Saga (over-50s) | 72% | 5★ | £60–£200 |
Prices are indicative monthly ranges for one adult, not quotes; age changes them far more than the insurer does. Prices by age and ways to pay less: how much private health insurance costs.
What a Good Health Insurance Quote Shows
Before you compare prices, check each quote clearly shows:
- the monthly and annual price, and whether Insurance Premium Tax is included (it normally is);
- the out-patient limit and what it covers (consultations, scans, tests);
- the hospital list by name, so you can check your local hospitals;
- the excess, and whether it’s per claim, per year or per person;
- the underwriting type, and any named exclusions;
- the cancer cover limits and how drugs are covered;
- mental health and therapies limits, if included;
- any no-claims discount and how a claim affects next year’s price.
If a quote leaves any of these out, ask before you buy.
Red Flags Behind a Cheap Quote
- No out-patient cover. The policy may only pay once you’re admitted, leaving you to fund the consultations and scans that come first.
- A narrow hospital list that leaves out the hospitals near you.
- A high excess per claim rather than per year, which costs more if you claim more than once.
- Limited cancer cover, such as caps on treatment or drugs.
- A six-week option you didn’t ask for, which means using the NHS if its wait is under six weeks.
- Switching onto new underwriting when you’re already insured, which can exclude conditions you’re covered for today.
Comparing at Renewal: Already Insured
If you already have private health insurance, the best time to compare is a few weeks before renewal. Ask your current insurer for your renewal price and your exact cover, then compare the same cover elsewhere.
- Ask for continued personal medical exclusions (CPME). The new insurer takes you on your current terms, so conditions covered today stay covered and you don’t start a new waiting period. CPME explained.
- Keep the dates continuous so there’s no gap, and don’t switch in the middle of treatment.
- Use the comparison to negotiate. A lower like-for-like price can help when you talk to your current insurer. How to negotiate your renewal.
Step by step: how to switch health insurance without losing cover. Coming off a work policy? See changing jobs and your health insurance.
FAQs: Comparing Private Health Insurance
How do I compare private health insurance?
Fix six settings first: out-patient limit, hospital list, excess, underwriting, cancer cover and extras. Then get quotes from at least three insurers on exactly those settings, check independent service scores such as Which?’s customer survey, and read each policy summary before you buy.
Is it free to compare health insurance?
Yes. Getting quotes from insurers, comparison services or brokers is normally free. Brokers are usually paid commission by the insurer, so using one shouldn’t cost you more than buying direct.
How many health insurance quotes should I get?
At least three, on the same cover, including one large insurer and one smaller one. The cheapest insurer for your age and postcode isn’t always a big name.
Why are my health insurance quotes so different?
Usually because the cover isn’t the same: a different out-patient limit, hospital list, excess or underwriting changes the price a lot. Even on identical cover, each insurer prices from its own claims experience, so prices still differ.
Can I compare health insurance if I have a pre-existing condition?
Yes. New buyers usually choose moratorium or full medical underwriting, which exclude past conditions in different ways. If you’re already insured and switching, ask for continued personal medical exclusions (CPME) so conditions covered now stay covered.
When should I compare if I’m already insured?
A few weeks before your renewal date. Get your renewal price and current cover from your insurer, compare the same cover elsewhere on CPME terms, and keep the dates continuous so there’s no gap.
Sources
- Customer scores: Which? – Best private health insurance (survey of people who had claimed, April 2026)
- Star ratings: Moneyfacts – Private Medical Insurance Star Ratings 2026
- Independent guidance: MoneyHelper – do you need private medical insurance?
- Check a broker or insurer is authorised: FCA Financial Services Register
Price ranges are indicative market ranges from our insurer research, last checked 26 October 2026. They are not quotes.
Important Information
This guide is independent general information, not financial advice. Prices are typical ranges and change over time; the only accurate figure is a personal quote. Cover terms, exclusions and underwriting vary by insurer and plan, so always check the policy documents before buying or switching, and never cancel existing cover before replacement cover is confirmed. Going Private UK is not affiliated with any insurer named. If you compare insurance quotes through this site, we may receive a commission from our FCA-regulated partners at no cost to you; this does not influence our guides.
Compare Like for Like
See the UK’s leading insurers side by side on the same cover, priced for your age and postcode. Free.
Compare QuotesFree · Independent · No obligationPrice





